Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> llms can make the promise of robots real

I think this is a very large overstatement. Many large problems still exist in robotics which can not be papered over with LLMs. I’m familiar with problems in manipulation and affordable sensing, which will not be solved via llms, and are fundamentally necessary for reliable and safe interaction with the real world. I’m confident there are many others. LLMs probably will help with high level planning. But that’s a subset of the many problems that keep robots from becoming mass market products.

I think people are excited about robotics because of the many demo videos that have been coming out of various companies. However, almost all of these videos are smoke and mirrors. If you ask somebody who works on those demos, they will unashamedly tell you all the ways they worked around their technical limitations to get just the right footage. The PR departments are less upfront with that info.



More on that in an article posted in October: "Why today's humanoids won't learn dexterity", https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45392922


Thanks for linking this! Rodney Brooks is great, in fact I was trying to remember his name to link some of his stuff, but somehow couldn't, lol.


They said AI, not LLMs. I'm not sure how LLMs would help specifically but AI in general is a large field.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: