Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Working means that you are providing value to others. As we advance as a society a single person is able to contribute more and more value to others. Why maintain the same amount of total value being added to society when we can push further and accelerate providing value to one another?


What we’re really talking about is freedom. Freedom to do what you want with your time whether it’s relaxation or work, but on your own terms.

When you have to work for an income that is a type of forced work, and generally speaking forced work is not going to be as effective as work done of your own volition.

It’s intrinsic motivation vs extrinsic motivation. When I think about your point of view I see a lot of waste and misery. Instead of naively maximizing value production, I want to see a future of contentment and quality value production. Value produced because people are inspired to produce value, not because they have to.


Working just means that you get paid to do something.

What you're rambling on about is some Ayn Randian technicality that has nothing to do with reality. The word "value" here means "non-measurable quantity in the neoclassical paradigm, approximated by indirect measure through unit of account", not anything meaningful.

A childcare worker raising children is "value". A mother raising her child is not "value". In other words, you're just measuring how much human activity conforms to a specific formalization.


Yep that's pretty much it.

If it was all about value, we wouldn't have people doing "work" who not only don't generate any material wealth but actually consume a lot of value for nothing very valuable in return.


By value you mean furthering the individualization and alienation by technology, which destroys the planet and gives us what, AI data centers? And the AI agents won't even do our jobs?


I'm convinced there are a large number of people, mostly in tech, that are unknowingly in a death cult because they think complex human systems can be boiled down to simple metrics and logic. And they get attached to this libertarian-type thinking because it makes them feel smart and above it all.

Like the rest of us are over-complicating it, and human economic prosperity is as simple as blindly accelerating value creation.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: