Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm a New Zealander and I think this is ridiculous. Anyway, I don't support mainstream media and instead buy as much as I can direct from the artists.

What I don't understand is why the government thinks this is a high priority.. there are far more serious issues to address and deal with.



It becomes a priority when there is serious lobbying by an industry with very deep pockets.


Yes it is ridiculous. The next logical step is to make it illegal to watch media you buy directly from the artists.


That would never happen. At least, I hope this would never happen...

That would require all forms of media be passed through a distribution chain, which would be ridiculous. But then again, this law seems ridiculous so let's wait and see.


For books that was the case in the past with the Stationer's Company in England. Everything had to pass through one of the members of the Stationer's Company. Copyright was invented to replace this system.


>That would require all forms of media be passed through a distribution chain, which would be ridiculous.

It will happen. It's very easy for the bad guys to mandate at some point that all media must be passed through a distribution chain.

It _has_ happened in other forms. For example, once (not that long ago, a few decades) you could buy food products direct from the source. Now it has been outlawed in almost extinction, e.g in France (similar laws exist in the US).

Food (cheese, wine, tomatoes, etc) to be sold, has to pass several BS tests and production criteria, that are "for the good of the public", but that in essence prohibit anyone but large industries to be selling it, putting an end to a centuries old tradition of small local producers.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: