Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

How about at first if we put camera on it and then someone from overseas checks around before performoning the task? for cheap but it can make it secure.


Sci-fi authors were worried about rebellions of enslaved robots, while the industry figures, why risk jumping into the unknown, when we can fake a smart computer with overseas labor and an Internet connection, and wage slavery we know how to handle...

Anyway, if we're going to fake smart robots this way, why not just honestly call it what it is? Remote household staff. Might as well give them better sensors and actuators, but I guess this is giving humans too much agency and risk; what if the operator decides to hurt the "robot" owners or something? The vendor would not have that. Cannot have that. Humans are too messy to deal with.

Or is this the short-term future of all automation? I look at my robotic vacuum cleaner now, occasionally pausing for a second or two while it figures out where to go, and I wonder - maybe in those moments, it's using some Protein Intelligence Chip to query a bunch of random humans somewhere?


I trust an ai model more than remote humans.


I’d rather not have someone from overseas walking around my home via remote cameras


Many chooses Amazon and Google to listen their home + record their home every day. Most customers just buy things.


AI = actually Indians


AI, the secret sauce that powered Amazon Fresh (or was it Amazon Go?)


Better than Alexa recorder


at that point, why not just have someone from overseas control the robot?


Because you can just have actual local people do it right there and then? The point of a robot is to not interact with other people, presumably they will be much more expensive than having someone come over for a few hours a week to clean - the whole appeal is there's no other human involved to coordinate or be nice to.


This is what happens with "autonomous" delivery robots that are operating on London campuses.

They are actually controlled by "robot operators" in Estonia, though officially it's "AI".

That being said, every day it's getting a little bit better.


> That being said, every day it's getting a little bit better.

Estonians are fast learners!


Because one remote overseas person can watch multiple camera feeds at once which should make the cost of a human-in-the-loop more palatable.


mm, good point!


Liability.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: