Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Talking about "public" and "in-state" is not the point.

College is mostly about the private institutions at a national level. That's where people would like to go.



Yes, but it's not where most actually go. 75% of degrees are awarded by public colleges and universities.


Maybe because most people can't afford the top private universities. But would have liked to go there.


They'd like to go to top universities because they're the best. Being private is just one more filter that stops poor people from getting the education they deserve.

Quality education can be public and free.


For my family, at least, private universities were much more affordable than (in-state) public...


It's more about capacity. There are hundreds more public universities than private. The money picture is ... messy and more complex. Some private universities are cheaper for low-income students than public schools (Harvard), some are drastically more expensive.

And not all private universities are "better" than all public universities. Think Berkeley, UT, umich, etc. All fantastic and in many areas clobber many / most private universities. There are some obvious outliers at the very top-ranked schools but, statistically, almost nobody goes to them.

It's messy and complex, but at the end of the day, the public universities educate drastically more people and generally do a good job of it; they have to be considered any time we talk about access to education.


I imagine prohibitive cost might act as a filter without explicit discrimination.


> Talking about "public" and "in-state" is not the point.

I think the point is about access to higher education.

> College is mostly about the private institutions at a national level. That's where people would like to go.

Where people would "like to go" is highly subjective, and the statistics would wildly disagree with your statement on where people actually go.


> College is mostly about the private institutions at a national level. That's where people would like to go.

Yeah, I think this is an uninformed take, and that many students never even consider a tier-1 private university. They attend their local university, or even a community college before transferring.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: