Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's just stupidity.

It should have no issue at all to align German wide but they never did it.

The Munich MVG for example is doing an experiment were you can pay by an app from some us company were you just start and stop your journey with a button and the app gives you the best price.

They could have instead just created some German wide software company sponsored by all the local public transport agencies and just do it themselves.

It's ridiculousl that modern problems are often not technical problems:-(



The issue is not the lack of technical expertise. The structure of the German public transport system is very localized, due to its historical growth. local networks are often owned by the municipalities that they are serving, the actual busses are sometimes provided by private companies on contract, the national railway carrier has contracts with state governments and certain local entities for specific services, national, state and local governments are subsidizing various services, etc.

I completely agree that it is a mess, but it is not really easy to solve with so many stakeholders and so many (sometimes conflicting but valid) different priorities at stake.


> They could have instead just created some German wide software company sponsored by all the local public transport agencies and just do it themselves.

But that already works with the »DB Navigator« app by Deutsche Bahn.

You can buy tickets for many local public transport companies. No need to download a custom app.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: