Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
GitHub Down Again?
60 points by sudmishra on Sept 7, 2022 | hide | past | favorite | 46 comments
Probably the second time in 12 hrs.


Yes, still having hiccups for me. I started having issues about 24 hours ago.

What is the reason for this spate of outages? GitHub is a mature, stable product. What core features could its engineers possibly need to be working on that whatever they did broke core backend functionality so badly?


Once Tableau was acquired by Salesforce, shit that had been stable as can be for YEARS started to break as Tableau (I assume) began to interface with SF systems or requirements. Last week, CLI functionality was down for 3-4 days, depending on the cluster you're on. Nothing like crushing production reporting for a week at the end of the month because Salesforce wants X, Y, and Z added to a mature product that had seen no issues for the 3 years prior.

My guess is that is the same sort of thing happening here w/Microsoft.


Might simply be infrastructure consolidation since Microsoft bought them. Same reason behind the Azure pipe / GitHub Actions mess.


GitHub actions is still a mess. I have outages once a week (variable time from minutes to hours).


Probably just Windows Update /s


What is even the point? https://www.githubstatus.com/

Save money by just not having the page or the people pretending they do something useful by maintaining it.


"operational" comes with strings attached. We don't know what internal SLAs specify but most likely the service is meeting those agreements.

Should we get a refund? :)


Maybe there's a business model here?

Sign up with Objective Uptime Inc. and tell them which vendors you have SLAs with. OU will monitor them on your behalf, compare the actual global availability to what's displayed on the vendor's status page, and if the outage exceeds agreed limits, OU can even automatically file suits on your behalf for breach of contract and misrepresentation (assuming the vendor's status page was showing all peachy).


Yes, my company is paying for my GH user seat.


"When a metric becomes a target, it ceases to be a good metric"

I regret that uptime became a clause in SLAs, or a reputation/marketing thing. I don't care about how many 9s are after your decimal, I just want to know if your service is down or if something is wrong on my end.


One of the many status page/"is it down" services could probably get some good PR out of having a GitHub status page that's based upon live results from several geographical locations..


Oh hey, I've got one right here: https://github.onlineornot.com/

Based out of Virginia, USA for the initial check, followed by a random sample of 19 locations around the world to confirm it's actually down.


They have reported incidents for the last two days but seem to limit it to a short amount of time which is clearly not the case for many folks out there.


I know over on AWS they are loath to update the status page since this is tied to SLA compensation. Does github have the same problem?


Again? Last time this happened was 12 - 13 hours ago [0]

If you are self-hosting like GNOME, wireguard, Redox OS, Wine, etc it seems it is business as usual. But for those who went all in on GitHub, it's pretty much a recurring disaster.

At this point, those who are self-hosting might as well say they have better up-time than GitHub had since they are still unreliable even after two years of warning against the 'centralize everything' [1] nonsense.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32744717

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22867803


Good to see it's not just me - seems to be flip-flopping: https://github.onlineornot.com/


Seemed like it had some short hiccups but seems fine again.

Edit: Shouldn't have posted that, seems like they still have some issues.


Downdetector shows both the outage last night and one this morning. https://downdetector.com/status/github/


Actions haven't run for me since two official outages ago. Multiple jobs stuck as "Waiting for a runner to pick up this job" for a day.


Yes. Lately there has been a lot of slowness and 500s.


Seems to be very slow, periodically works.


It's up, it's just really slow


Yeah, definitely having some problems.


Remember when git came out, one of its features was being a decentralized, distributed version control system? Yeah.


Every time there's an outage with $SCMProvider, there's always a comment like this.

Git is not GitHub. GitHub is not git.

You can absolutely do git in a distributed way.

That doesn't help when your business workflow relies on GitHub for access control, artifact hosting, issue management, PR coordination & approval, and all the thousand other things that people use GitHub for.


I mean... it still is? I can work on my codebase and commit on my local machine. Push remote to Gitlab if Github is down. When Github is back up I can push to Github. What's the problem?


Do you have the same build and deploy pipeline configured in GitLab as well? If so, congrats, you are nailing it.


To answer most comments here, of course git is still decentralized, it’s just that almost no one use it like that. We chose the easier route, as usual. Just like most people don’t host their texts and photos on their own site.

I simply expected more from us nerds.


It still is one, but it’s easier to work with it if there’s a single source of truth.

You can still work on your Git tree, you just can’t sync with this SSOT.


Note that your repo stays usable even while GitHub is down, and your team can sync their work afterwards. Or if you prefer, you can switch to a different remote without much trouble.

On a different note, I do host my own Git server, but between maintainance downtime, power outages and ISP issues, my availability isn't nearly as good as GitHub's.


This joke is more beaten than Github at this point.


Git is decrentralized! You win GitHub down bingo!


I don’t know. If it keeps happening again and again and people keep bringing it up, maybe it’s a remake worth considering.


Still better than bitbucket


It's having a moment.


One of many.


Decentralize them.


Definitely...


Yes


Seems to be up for me


same here


unicorns here



> Repost: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32735734

LOL, this clearly shows how grave the situation is. Guess it's time to listen again to: https://youtu.be/XimyEvDJWzA


That post is a day old


Then its about time that Github fixes the issue.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: