Side-loading and alternative app stores via EU order can't come soon enough. Too many digital eggs in one digital basket, too much control by a corp for something that is so influential on society.
The nanosecond bad actors (e.g., mega corps) can have apps exclusively in these alt stores, that’s when those corps will move, reinsert their anti-consumer code that Apple makes them take out, and have that be the only choice. And these mega corps will tell consumers about what’s in there as much as they used to before Apple added the mandatory disclosures which is — not disclose at all.
Also, it’s much easier to make peace with Apple choosing what can be snapped into a modular PDA (personal digital assistant) if you stop distinguishing between hardware and software as if that distinction matters for an appliance, and consider it all firmware and all part of a singular trusted digital experience: “Don’t make me think.”
Today, consumers can choose trusted curation and full integration (iDevices), or non-curated and unbundled (countless brand + Android OS options).
If alt app stores happen, consumers will lose this choice, because nobody will be left counter balancing the exploiting corporations’ power. The race to monetizing exploitation happening before Apple stepped in will continue apace.
If that's the case, shouldn't we have seen this behavior on Android? The Play Store has all kind of restrictions and it has always been possible to create you own store and only offer your apps in that store. Yet you can download apps from every mega corp in the Play store.
> Today, consumers can choose trusted curation and full integration (iDevices), or non-curated and unbundled (countless brand + Android OS options).
Or option 3: curated and integrated by buying an Android phone that comes bundled with all kinds of Google applications.
> nobody will be left counter balancing the exploiting corporations’ power
The 3 major computing platform vendors Apple, Microsoft, and Google are 3 of the 4 largest corporations in the world by market cap. They are the corporate power with no counterbalance.
I don't have any skin in the game in terms of Apple anymore. I use Android these days, and I use F-Droid, and all the apps on it are FOSS and possible to audit. If privacy/security is a concern, the only winning move is not to play with closed source OS and firmware on devices.
Side-loading and installing from binary blobs is the counter-balancing choice: don't use any third-party app store, pick-and-choose what you run. Not to do any disservice to F-Droid, it's an excellent option, but only doing what you could do by hand.
Even if apple is less powerful, nobody will be forced to download Facebook or fortnite, and you can instead continue to just use the apple app store. Apps will continue to be added that meet apple's expectations because people trust spending money there.
If your worry was founded, these apps already wouldn't be on Apple devices because they'd be androind-only
The mega corps are angling for marketing dollars (ad spend) and those with marketing dollars want the audiences with “wallet share” and when split that way, those audiences are something like 85% iOS, 15% Android.
This means the megacorps “have to” play nice on iOS in order to serve up monied audiences to their advertisers.
If consumers are choosing Apple for their trusted curation, why would those same consumers no longer stick to the Apple's own App Store?
If exploiting corporations were so all-powerful, why do they have to release on Apple devices at all? Why wouldn't they just exclusively release it on platforms they can exploit? Because consumers demand it. Those same consumers can demand it on the Apple App Store.
It won't help. Case in point: Steam. If your indie game isn't on it you can as well not release it at all, as the money you collect will be a pittance.
IMO, this is trying to draw analogies where there doesn't need to be any. I work in games myself, but this isn't particularly relevant.
A better comparison is Google Play versus F-Droid. Yup. The overwhelming majority of people get their utility apps from Google Play still. However, for anyone who cares to do so, there is F-Droid, Amazon, and plenty of others that offer more than just utility apps, including Epic Games app where countless folks download Fortnite, if you want to bring it back to video games and the success or misinformed lack thereof with third-party platforms.
With the likes of F-Droid, everything on it is free, mate. It is free as in beer and free as in freedom, it's FLOSS. Money doesn't enter the equation, but everything is possible to audit.
Like I told another user: If you care about these things, the only winning move is not to play. Ergo, it's there for anybody who cares to seek it out.
Let's bring it back to games again. Fortnite was removed from the App Store. You bet that Epic Games would have released their own Epic Games app just like on Android to get iOS users playing Fortnite again. If you don't think that it would have been a huge success just like on Android then I can only laugh. So many young folks switched from iOS to Android to keep playing Fortnite.
