Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I can't say how precisely the delineation of Uber's alleged accounting schemes are true but all of the same can be said for public transit such as light rail. Los angeles for example loses 2 billion per year on their metro (before covid) not including the 27 billion overall (non inflation adjusted) that was poured into it's construction.

It would probably be cheaper to pay for the Uber fares of all the people that use the metro to use Uber instead.

The author has an obvious political worldview and must fit all information rigidly into it.

Edit: NYC subway loses 7 billion a year before covid when you remove it's tax revenue (government subsidy).



Public services don't need to make money. What we spend on those services isn't "losing money", it's spending tax money on a service that benefits all of us. Train (and bus) lines reduce traffic, cost less, and fuel commerce along their routes. Your estimate of what's being "lost" doesn't account for the economic gains that come along with public transport, which is estimated at 4x the cost of investment: https://www.apta.com/research-technical-resources/economic-i...

Spending that by funneling it into a private service (privatization) usually results in worse service at a higher cost. Specifically funding Uber reenforces building the city out for cars, rather than for people, making it more expensive to properly fund public transportation.


Public transportation is heavily subsidized. But liquidating it because it’s not profitable would cause extreme traffic congestion. The city would cease to function. Buses and trains are a multiplier for capacity.

Private transportation is also heavily subsidized. Usually it’s in indirect ways like the government paying for roads and airports, mandating parking minimums, and keeping driver licensing lax. There’s rarely direct budget line items to keep fares low. But make no mistake marshaling capital and land are huge subsidies.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: