Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

huh? there’s plenty of colleges to choose from and yet costs go up every year.

to me it seems like a distortion caused by a Federal Gov that guarantees payment to universities in the form of federally backed student loans.



supply/demand

you are right, the demand is artificially propped up by the govt. as you stated.

However, it is tied to the job market, which is more realistic, and we are starting to see the fallout where many of the colleges will be going out of business.


Education is now a Veblen good.


I agree that it is presently such.

I disagree that it's ever been otherwise.


Subsidized corn is not rapidly and consistently increasing in price.


I don’t necessarily buy the idea that student loans are driving price increases, but there’s a tangible difference between subsidizing producers versus consumers (corn subsidies are generally the former, student loans are the latter).


If people couldn't get the loans the price wouldn't be that high, people don't have the money to pay it.


education is a highly inelastic good...couple that with essentially unlimited federally back loans and you get price increases year after year


Corn is an example of subsidized supply.

Government money increases the supply of corn, and drives the price down. Hence, corn, and products derived from it -- high-fructose corn syrup (HFCS), corn-fed beef, Nu Metal bands, etc -- are cheaper.

College is an example of subsidized demand.

Government money increases the number of prospective students, by lowering the financial barrier to attend university. The result being that the cost of a university education has risen, drastically, while the quality of that education has plummeted.


education is not a commodity in the same sense as corn

and it’s much more of an inelastic good than corn

the difference between 50k in tuition and expenses and 55k will not change demand a meaningful amount, and universities exploit the fact that education is inelastic and the money is coming from a guaranteed source regardless of the student’s ability to pay upfront.


The reason for the subsidies is to support farmers by offsetting what would otherwise be price decreases, so...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: