Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There's no way this ban will apply to governments though. Just like that right to remove PII, governments are exempt. The article already mentions exceptions for security.


Governments aren't exempt from all privacy laws; in fact, just last month the Data Protection Commission in my EU country blocked the police from installing cameras in public places.

That said, I can see some countries vetoing such an EU-wide ban if it applied to all law enforcement.


At least in the Netherlands there’s the same loophole as in the US: the police can give a camera to a private party, point it to the street and get access to the feed.


You're generally not allowed to point a camera at public roads in the Netherlands: https://www.politie.nl/themas/camera-in-beeld.html?sid=05783...


Not sure how you’re going to hang up a Ring doorbell then. And the police surely doesn’t mind if you ‘accidentally’ capture ‘part of’ public space, as long as you share your images with them.


If you cannot do it without filming public space, then you don't. Simple as that.

(If you've got a garden in front of your house or so, I don't see a problem)


Strong words but they don’t mean anything. Reality shows the doorbells are selling and people are not getting arrested.


In my country the municipality does fine people directing surveillance cameras towards the street


But do they if it’s not a scary camera but a doorbell instead?


If it is filming, of course. Do you think they are idiots and don't know that smart doorbells exist?


Privacy regulators don't have people patrolling the streets, that doesn't mean they won't act if they get a complaint.


That doesn't sound like it's compatible with GDPR. In Austria some bar was fined because their security cameras were pointing at the public street:

https://edpb.europa.eu/news/national-news/2018/first-austria...


This matches precisely none of the practical experience I've had. The police is the police, they're going to be evil bastards when they can get away with it - but in this case I'd like to see some legislative proof that this is actually true.


But state owned institutions can not be fined under the GDPR, which makes it tough to enforce it against government entities.


The GDPR isn't the only privacy law in the EU.


> There's no way this ban will apply to governments though

It's a good thing even if it doesn't apply to governments, although it would be even better if it did.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: