Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

A word test isn’t an IQ test. Nobody is disputing that tests in general can be culturally biased, but we are talking about IQ tests specifically.


Word tests are used as part of good, high quality IQ tests (e.g. WAIS and Stanford-Binet, though obviously not Raven’s). They are in fact one of the most useful and predictive parts (I.e. they are most g-loaded). They are biased (i.e. not measurement invariant) if you compare subjects from different countries/cultures, but they are not biased if you compare subjects from the same country/culture. For example, the score on word analogies sections has exact same predictive validity for white Americans as it does for black Americans. See Arthur Jensen’s “Bias in mental testing” for a very comprehensive treatise on the issue.


They use (or used) word tests for IQ.

Things like 'bear is to dog as fish is to: a) flower b) whale c) door d) donkey' ... kind of thing.

It's not supposed to test language proficiency, but it can have an effect.


Wonderful example in the same vein from my secondary school English teacher:

Black and (a) white, (b) blue, (c) proud, (d) decker.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: