You're basically doing it yourself. Trying to dismiss it with adjectives as "half-baked" or "stupid".

The point is, it's neither and I think it deserves a proper dismissal instead of ad-hominems and insults.

Surely there is someone that can perform a point by point analysis and disprove the memo? I have not seen one comment doing that. Not one.

So no, you don't get to say it's stupid and call it a day. Prove it.