Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | moshei's commentslogin

By the age you would be able to consent (between 13 and 18 years depending on country) it would be a major surgical procedure involving days or weeks of pain, not the few minutes a baby experiences.

Babies are remarkable in their ability to heal and adapt.


Calling this mutilation is absurd, I am circumcised and so is my son - it was way more traumatic for me seeing, then it was for him feeling t - many babies do not even cry.

I suggest you do a little more research on what genital mutilation really means in the 3rd world, circumcision is no worse than some injections by comparison.

There is a very valid medical reason for this - it prevents sexually transmitted diseases [1] - So much so that it is promoted for adult males by health organizations. n the other hand, the foreskin serves absolutely no medical purpose.

Most reputable mohels (specially trained people who conduct the circumcision) will use a tube to suck the blood to prevent any chance of infection.

[1] http://www.who.int/hiv/topics/malecircumcision/en/


That link had already been posted: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14292131

Also, whether something is mutilation or not is about more than how much it hurts when it's done. In this case a child is deprived of a part of their body that performs a clear biological function.


I would disagree that the foreskin performs an essential biological function, and by the dictionary definition that would not make it mutilation.


I said clear, not essential. Your pinky finger also does not perform an essential biological function, i.e. you can keep on living without it. But it performs a clear one, providing more grip strength and options.

Please link to the dictionary definition you're using.



( If you're responding quickly, click the time link to get a reply field. )

From the definition: "make imperfect by removing or irreparably damaging parts" Cutting off the foreskin entirely fulfills that description.


I suggest you look at this: http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/

Using the term mutilation when it is most often used in that context is absurd.


Mutilation has a clear meaning in the dictionary and its application here is perfectly fine.


So if a girl gets FGM and doesnt cry its ok? Are you insane? So if one is induced with anesthesia and they cut your arm off its ok then? MGM = FGM, and you denied a child a choice when there was no immediate danger. I wish I had the choice. I had the cahones to let me son remain un-mutilated and if he dislikes it so much he can lop it off. Think for yourself. Question authority.


Technical Writer - Johannesburg, South Africa - Onsite, Remote or permanent part time

We are looking for a talented technical writer to help us improve our suite of documentation and training materials.

Skills & Duties

   * Ability to understand highly technical concepts and communicate them effectively to less technical users
   * Create and update all technical content including: 
      * User Guides
      * Tutorials
      * Blogs
      * Knowledge Base Articles
      * Instructional Videos
      * Training Course Material
      * Sales Proposals
   * Experience with UX and information design preferred 
About Egis Software

Egis Software is an established software vendor of Enterprise Content Management solutions in the South African, Botswana, Mauritius and UK regions.

Email your resume and writing samples to resumes@egis-software.com


Egis Software (www.egis-software.com) - Johannesburg, South Africa or Remote

We are looking for a talented senior developer to help us grow and scale the various products in our commercial product suite.

You will be part of the core team building cutting edge software using agile techniques and practises.

You will develop new functionality as well as play a key role in code reviews, design sessions and mentoring junior developers.

Skills & Requirements:

  - Strong development skills preferably with modern Java and Javascript 
  - Experience with setting up and configuring Linux servers and databases (preferably via automation) 
  - Experience implementing and scaling test automation 
  - Ability to learn new languages and technologies quickly 
  - DevOps experience a big plus
Our stack:

  - Moden Java incl JAX-RS, CDI, Jetty and Groovy, Hibernate, Hazelcast 
  - Sencha Touch, Phonegap , ExtJS, Bootstrap, AngularJS 
  - Jenkins, Selenium / Webdriver 
  - PostgreSQL, MySQL, SQL Server, Lucene, Mongo 
  - Python  - Primarily for system automation using ansible 
  - Ubuntu, Graylog2, VMWare, AWS
Send an email to resumes@egis-software.com and mention HN in the subject


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: